Tuesday’s decision to allow “white spaces” for WiFi-like services on unused television frequencies, represents a new era to provide broadband wireless using unlicensed devices.
One potential use that could come from the decision is neighborhood wireless zones. Carriers could provide, for example, rural broadband Internet access without incurring the huge costs of buying spectrum for a limited number of subscribers.
Roger Cochetti, group director of U.S. Public Policy for the Computing Technology Industry Association, said the FCC’s ruling will soon make Internet access “appear as common and ubiquitous as air” and will work to collapse the digital divide. The Wireless Innovation Alliance includes Microsoft, Google, Motorola, HP and many other high tech firms.
In his blog, Larry Page, Google co-founder referred to that as “Wi-Fi on steroids.” He also praised the FCC for adopting the same successful unlicensed model used for Wi-Fi. “Now that the FCC has set the rules, I’m sure that we’ll see similar growth in products to take advantage of this spectrum.
Yesterday FCC Chairman Kevin Martin and fellow commissioners unanimously agreed with proponents of free public access, including Google and Microsoft. The FCC in October released a report (pdf) that found the interference issue to be inconsequential, and noted that, “when factoring in actual operation under nonstatic conditions, the situation only improves.” They also noted that wireless microphones would be protected in several ways. For example, the commission has mandated that devices include the ability to listen to the airwaves to sense wireless microphones as an additional measure of protection for these devices.
Full power analog television broadcasts operate between the 54 MHz and 806 MHz in the United States (Channels 2-69). In February 2009, full power TV stations will be required to switch to digital transmission and operate only between 54-698 MHz.
The space between 698-806 MHz (in the 700 MHz band) was auctioned off by the FCC in 2007, netting some $19 billion for the U.S. Treasury. Those new licenses will be combined with the 700 MHz auction winners in 2002 to provide expanded cellular range for Verizon, AT&T and Qualcomm’s MediaFLO.
One of the advantages of DTV is that million watt DTV television stations can operate on adjacent channels (ie Ch 41, 42, 43…) because a digital signal can more easily filter out interference. That also frees up lots of unused open channels. Adjacent channels had to lie fallow in the analog era.
The broadcast television spectrum is even lower than the highly coveted 700 MHz band. It should transmit further and penetrate better than today’s Wi-Fi technology, so broadband access can be spread using fewer base stations. But power will be limited using these unlicensed devices and the bandwidth is only the width of one (unused) television channel (6 MHz). That’s less than one third the bandwidth of one 20Mhz channel found on the unlicensed 2.4 GHz band (which is 85MHz wide).
According to Martin’s description, portable devices that use both spectrum-sensing technology and geolocation databases to prevent interference to DTV would be limited to 100 mW of power, or 40 mW when operating on channels adjacent to active DTV channels. If the devices use only spectrum sensing, they would be limited to 50 mW, or 40 mW on adjacent channels.
The Association for Maximum Service Television said that the 40 mW level on adjacent channels would “eviscerate” DTV in some areas, particularly in cities.
“Motorola looks forward to developing products to market that will help consumers realize the full potential of the TVWS including the opportunity to make broadband access, as well as other communication services, available to millions of underserved Americans,” said Greg Brown, president and co-CEO of Motorola. Motorola expects to have White Space access points on the market in a year or two.
A white spaces access point will use the IEEE 802.22 standard ( wikipedia), which utilizes two different strategies to avoid interference. First, it listens for other users, and moves to another channel if there’s the potential to cause interference. But this technique is only partially successful. For example, an access point in the “shadow” of a building may not detect a distant tv station. An ajoining house, with a clear shot to the distant television station, might then pick up both transmitters on the same channel, causing interference.
The second technique — required in “white space” access points — would utilize GPS to determine the radios position and interrogate the FCC’s list of broadcast transmitters. Access points would automatically avoid using nearby television channels based on its location.
Related DailyWireless stories include; NAB: Blowblack on Whitespace, White Spaces: Green Light from FCC Report, White Space Field Testing, Welcome to the White Space, Microsoft Disputes FCC Unlicensed Finding, FCC: License-free 700MHz Devices Failed Test, Broadcasters: Portable Devices Kill DTV, Mud Fight in White Space, Pushing for “White Space”, White Space Pow Wow, White Space Gets Hot, Martin New FCC Head, FCC Broadband Taskforce Recommendations, Consumers to FCC: 700MHz Democracy Now!, Broadband Wireless — Hello Goodbye, Microsoft’s “Free” Phone?, Bills Expand Unlicensed UHF Access, 700MHz Battle Begins, Cognitive Brains Self Organize, Unlicensed 700Mhz Access, HiWire: 24 Mobile TV Channels, MobileTV: Modeo KOed by Crown, Mobile/Handheld TV: Killer App?, Mobile TV War at NAB, NAB 2007: Dead Man Walking?, MediaFlo Debuts March 1st, NYC Mobile TV Delayed, Hiwire Moves on Mobile TV, Mobile TV: Six Flavors and Unlicensed Spectrum: The Sum of All Fears.
